I recently joined Patrick Ellis on The Diesel Podcast to talk about what happens to a diesel truck's value after an accident or a total loss. If you take one thing away, make it this: endorse your upgrades.
Patrick's show is usually about the fun side of diesel ownership: swaps, tunes, lifts, and builds. This episode was the responsible side. Diesel owners put thousands of dollars into their trucks, and most never think about what happens to that investment if the truck is damaged or totaled. Here are the main points we covered.
Endorse Your Upgrades
This is the most important thing a diesel owner can do. Auxiliary fuel tanks, suspension lifts, custom wheels and tires, and other aftermarket parts usually are not covered by a standard auto policy unless you add them to it, which insurers call an endorsement.
Just a couple of weeks before the recording, I worked a total loss with a $3,600 auxiliary fuel tank. The market supported the value, but the owner never endorsed it, so there was no coverage and nothing to recover. Wheels are another common one. If an unendorsed $1,000 wheel is damaged, you may get a used replacement worth a fraction of that.
What to Do
Call your insurer about every upgrade, however small it seems. Ask what it would cost to endorse it and how it would be covered. Some carriers endorse a set dollar amount. Then decide whether the added premium is worth it for you.
Endorsements matter for repairs too, not just total losses. See do aftermarket upgrades count in a total loss settlement.
Keep Every Receipt
Major work like a new engine or transmission is treated differently from customizations. Insurers call it a refurbishment, and documented refurbishments can add value back to a totaled truck. You will not get dollar for dollar, but without receipts you may get nothing for it.
Imagine spending $25,000 on an engine replacement and having the truck totaled a month later with an $18,000 offer. Shops open and close all the time, so do not count on them to keep your records. Save digital copies of every invoice for repairs, maintenance, and upgrades.
Check Your Policy for an Appraisal Clause
Most people have never heard of the appraisal clause, but most auto policies include one. It lets you dispute your insurer's total loss valuation, with each side naming an appraiser. Look at your policy now so you know what it says before you ever need it.
I used my own appraisal clause earlier this year when a drunk driver totaled my Silverado Trail Boss in front of my house. Had I not known about it, I would have been underpaid by about $8,000. Learn more in our guide on how to dispute a total loss valuation.
Why Diesel Valuations Go Wrong
Diesel trucks are a small, specialized market. Owners keep them a long time and shop for the exact truck they want, so there are fewer comparable vehicles for sale. Valuation software picks the closest matches it can find, and with diesels those are sometimes gas trucks, the wrong trim, or the wrong drivetrain. It is not intentional. The market is just thin.
About a month before the recording, we helped the owner of a 2021 GMC Sierra 3500 get about $8,000 more after his valuation compared it with gas trucks and the wrong trims. Older diesels are a big part of this too. A clean, low-mileage diesel that is 15 or 20 years old can be worth far more than a general guide suggests, and those values are often easier to support.
Review Your Valuation
When you get a total loss offer, look past the bottom number. Check that the comparable vehicles are diesels with the same trim, drivetrain, and options. See how insurers determine actual cash value.
Diminished Value on Diesel Trucks
Diminished value can be harder to prove on diesels, because many buyers are focused on the truck's purpose and capability and are less concerned about accident history. It still exists, especially on newer trucks.
Shortly before the show, we worked a 2025 Super Duty whose diminished value claim the insurer had initially denied. There was no frame damage, but the repair included a bedside replacement and cab corner work. The claim went from $0 to about $6,800. Newer aluminum bodies also mean more parts are replaced instead of repaired, which can affect both repair cost and value. Learn more about diminished value reports.
Fleets, Floods, and Hail
We also talked about businesses with multiple trucks. A flood or hailstorm can take out a whole fleet at once, and the pressure to get replacements quickly makes it tempting to accept the first settlement. Take a moment to review each valuation first. With hail damage, a work truck that is totaled may sometimes be kept and still driven, depending on your state and insurer. See can you keep your car after it is totaled.
Thanks to The Diesel Podcast
Thank you to Patrick Ellis for having me on The Diesel Podcast. You can watch the full episode on YouTube.
If your diesel truck was totaled and the offer does not look right, we are happy to review it. If the offer is fair, we will tell you. Rules vary by state, so you can also check your state guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are diesel upgrades covered if my truck is totaled?
Often not, unless they are endorsed on your policy. Standard policies usually do not cover aftermarket parts like auxiliary fuel tanks, lifts, or custom wheels. Call your insurer to add them.
Does a new engine increase my truck's total loss value?
It can. Major replacements are treated as refurbishments and may add value if you have receipts. You will not usually get back the full amount you spent.
Why was my diesel truck compared with gas trucks?
The diesel market is small, so valuation software may pick the closest vehicles it can find. Review the comparables and dispute the valuation if they do not match your truck.
What is an appraisal clause?
A provision in many auto policies that lets you dispute your insurer's valuation. You and your insurer each name an appraiser, and an umpire may decide if they cannot agree.
Think Your Total Loss Valuation Missed Something?
Premier Vehicle Valuation Specialists prepares independent, market-based total loss valuations and represents vehicle owners through the appraisal clause for a flat $449 fee.
Before you commit to anything, we review your claim information. If an appraisal is unlikely to make a meaningful difference, we will tell you.
This article provides general information about vehicle property damage claims and is not legal or tax advice. Insurance requirements, claim procedures, and available remedies vary by state, policy, and individual circumstances.









