Umpire Service

Neutral Insurance Appraisal Umpire Services

Premier provides neutral umpire services for diminished value and total loss appraisal disputes. When appraisers are unable to reach an agreed resolution, we independently review the competing valuations, supporting documentation, comparable vehicle data, and claim related evidence to assist in resolving the disputed amount fairly and objectively.
Flat Fee: $599 Nationwide Where Permitted.

Is Umpire Service Right for Your Dispute?

  • Umpire Services

    ✔ The two appraisers have been unable to reach an agreement

    ✔ An appraisal clause dispute is already underway

    ✔ A neutral third party is needed to review the dispute

    ✔ Want an independent review of both appraisals and supporting documentation

    ✔ Need assistance resolving a diminished value or total loss valuation dispute

    ✔ Prefer an objective, evidence based evaluation process

    ✔ Looking for efficient dispute resolution without litigation


    Request Umpire Services


    (Available Nationwide Where Permitted)

How the Umpire Process Works


  1. Both appraisers submit their valuation reports and supporting documentation
  2. We independently review the competing appraisals and claim evidence
  3. We evaluate comparable vehicle data, market support, and valuation methodology
  4. We communicate with both appraisers as needed throughout the process
  5. We work toward a fair and evidence supported resolution of the disputed amount



* Available Nationwide Where Permitted

Interested in our services? We’re here to help!

We want to know your needs exactly so that we can provide the perfect solution. Let us know what you want and we’ll do our best to help.

Request Umpire Services