How to Read a Mitchell or Audatex Total Loss Valuation Report

William Heck • November 16, 2026

Some insurers use Mitchell or Audatex instead of CCC ONE to value totaled vehicles. The reports look different, but they answer the same questions, and you should review them the same way.

Mitchell and Audatex are two other widely used valuation providers. Whichever system your insurer uses, the report is built from the same ingredients: your vehicle's details, comparable vehicles, adjustments, and a summary. Request the complete report from your adjuster.

What These Reports Have in Common

Section What to check
Vehicle description VIN, trim, engine, drivetrain, and mileage
Equipment and options Every package and option on your window sticker
Condition How your vehicle was rated and the resulting adjustment
Comparable vehicles Trim, mileage, location, source, and the adjustments applied
Market or base value How the comparables were combined into a single value
Settlement summary Condition and prior-damage adjustments, taxes, fees, and deductible

Differences You May Notice

  • Layout and terminology. Each provider labels sections differently. Look for the comparable vehicle list and the adjustment details, wherever they appear.
  • Data sources. Providers draw on different combinations of dealer listings, sales data, and inventory feeds, so comparables may differ.
  • How adjustments are shown. Some reports show each adjustment line by line for every comparable. Others summarize. If the detail is not shown, ask for it.
  • Weighting. Some reports weight comparables differently based on distance, age of the listing, or similarity. Ask how the final value was calculated.

A Review Checklist for Any Valuation Report

1 Verify your vehicle

Confirm the trim, options, and mileage against your window sticker and records.

2 Check each comparable

Are they the same trim, similar mileage, and reasonably close to you? See what makes a comparable vehicle comparable.

3 Question large adjustments

A comparable that needs a big adjustment may not be a good comparable.

4 Review condition and prior damage

Make sure deductions are supported by photos or inspection notes.

5 Confirm taxes and fees

See what taxes and fees a total loss settlement should include.

Same Rules, Different Format

The valuation provider does not change the standard: the settlement should reflect your vehicle's actual cash value in your local market. If the report does not, you can provide corrections and supporting evidence. See our guide on how to read a CCC ONE report for more on each section.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which valuation provider is most accurate?

Accuracy depends less on the provider than on the inputs: correct vehicle details, truly comparable vehicles, and supported adjustments. Any report can be accurate or contain errors.

Can I ask the insurer to use a different valuation method?

You can provide your own evidence, such as comparable listings or an independent appraisal. Whether the insurer changes its method depends on its practices and state regulations.

What if the report does not show the comparables?

Ask the adjuster for the full report, including each comparable vehicle and its adjustments.

Think Your Total Loss Valuation Missed Something?

Premier Vehicle Valuation Specialists prepares independent, market-based total loss valuations and represents vehicle owners through the appraisal clause for a flat $449 fee.

Before you commit to anything, we review your claim information. If an appraisal is unlikely to make a meaningful difference, we will tell you.

Request an Evaluation

This article provides general information about vehicle property damage claims and is not legal or tax advice. Insurance requirements, claim procedures, and available remedies vary by state, policy, and individual circumstances.

Modern car interior with steering wheel and navigation screen
By William Heck • November 18, 2026
How total loss valuations rate your vehicle's pre-accident condition, how that affects the payout, and what evidence supports a better condition rating.
Row of late-model SUVs parked on a dealership lot
By William Heck • November 17, 2026
Comparable vehicles drive most total loss valuations. Learn what makes a good comparable, which ones to question, and how to find better ones yourself.
Person reviewing handwritten notes and a laptop at a desk
By William Heck • November 13, 2026
A section-by-section guide to the CCC ONE market valuation report insurers use on many total losses, and what to check on each page before you accept.
Vehicles parked in a fenced storage lot
By William Heck • November 12, 2026
Towing and storage fees can add up quickly after an accident. Learn who pays them, how to keep them from growing, and what to do if you are charged.
The Diesel Podcast logo with a red gear in the word podcast
By William Heck • November 10, 2026
Diesel upgrades often are not covered after a total loss. What I shared on The Diesel Podcast about endorsements, receipts, and diesel truck valuations.
Professionals meeting with a client at a table
By William Heck • November 10, 2026
Appraiser, public adjuster, or attorney? Learn what each professional does in a vehicle property damage claim and when each one makes sense.
Close-up of vehicle engine components
By William Heck • November 9, 2026
What is the difference between OEM, aftermarket, and used parts in a collision repair, when insurers use each, and how parts choices can affect value.
Hands holding a blank sheet of paper at a desk
By William Heck • November 6, 2026
A property damage demand letter lists everything the at-fault driver's insurer owes you after an accident. Learn what to include, with a sample letter.
Person holding up car keys in front of a vehicle
By William Heck • November 5, 2026
Who pays for a rental car after an accident, and what is loss of use? Learn how rental coverage works on first-party and third-party claims.
Insurance claim paperwork and a pen on a table
By William Heck • November 4, 2026
Why diminished value claims are denied or reduced, from missing documentation to filing against the wrong policy, and how to avoid the most common problems.